GTA 6 Has Near-Perfect Critic Reviews, But Players Aren’t Fully Convinced: 6 Reasons

Why does GTA 6 have a 99 critic score but a much lower user score? We break down the critic reviews, 6 reasons players aren’t convinced and the review-bombing reports.

GTA 6 key art with the text “Why Players Disagree with Critics?” showing strong critic reviews and mixed player sentiment

Why is GTA 6 sitting near the top of critic scoreboards while its user rating looks dramatically lower? The short answer is that critics and players are judging the same release through different lenses, and the early user score has also been affected by a reported wave of extreme ratings. Neither number, on its own, tells you whether you will enjoy the game.

Key takeaways

  • Metacritic’s PS5 critic score was reported at 99/100 from 152 reviews on November 21, 2026 (GGRecon).
  • The Metacritic user score moved between reported snapshots: 5.4 to 5.6 was reported on November 21. The earlier 4.9 figure should be treated as a dated report, not today’s score.
  • IGN, GameSpot and Game Informer awarded GTA 6 10/10; TechRadar’s review was 5/5.
  • Push Square & GGrecon reported a wave of zero-score reviews, but not every negative review can be count illegitimate.
  • Circana data reported average launch-day playtime of 513 minutes on PS5 and 494 minutes on Xbox among players who played GTA 6 that day.
Bar chart of reported GTA 6 Metacritic user score snapshots: 4.9, 5.4, 5.5 and 5.6 out of 10
Reported GTA 6 Metacritic user score snapshots after user reviews opened. Sources: Tech4Gamers, Push Square, GGRecon.

Why critics gave GTA 6 such a high score

The first reviews appeared on November 18, a day before the November 19 launch on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. Metacritic’s PS5 listing was reported at 99 from 152 critic reviews on November 21. OpenCritic’s Top Critic Average also shifted as more reviews arrived, so any figure there needs a timestamp rather than being presented as permanent.

IGN and GameSpot each awarded 10/10 (see the OpenCritic review list and PC Gamer’s review roundup), Game Informer’s Matt Miller also gave it a perfect score, and TechRadar gave the game 5/5. Reviews praised Leonida’s scale and detail, the activities beyond the main missions, and the relationship between Jason and Lucia.

Critics assessed the complete package: world design, presentation, narrative, character work and exploration. A 10/10 is an overall judgement, not a claim that every element is flawless. For context on the hype that built up before launch, see why GTA 6 was dubbed the first “AAAAA” game.

6 reasons players aren’t fully convinced

 

Six reasons GTA 6 players are not fully convinced: 30fps, story pacing, life sim balance, expectations, zero-score ratings and unverified user scores
The six main reasons behind the gap between GTA 6 critic and user scores.

The contrast became striking when Metacritic user reviews opened on November 20. Tech4Gamers reported an early user score of 4.9, and later snapshots on November 21 were reported at around 5.4, 5.5 and 5.6. When GGRecon checked the PS5 page on the morning of November 21, it showed a user score of 5.5 from 34,804 ratings. These are the six main reasons behind the gap.

1. The 30fps target on console

One recurring complaint is the 30-frames-per-second target on console. Players who expected a 60fps mode may find that disappointing, especially in a major release built around fast driving and action. Not every reviewer sees it as a problem, though: Pure Xbox’s reviewer said the frame rate quickly became a non-issue. If performance matters most to you, our guide to PC vs console vs mobile gaming explains the trade-offs.

2. Story pacing

Other complaints focus on the story’s pacing. Even TechRadar’s five-star review noted that the narrative feels a bit slower than GTA 5, particularly at the beginning. Critics still praised the story overall, so this is one area where professional and player opinions clearly split.

3. The balance between action and life simulation

Some players question the balance between action and life-simulation elements. Push Square noted that some users made specific criticisms of these life-simulation systems rather than simply giving the game a zero.

4. It isn’t the GTA some players wanted

Some players are judging whether GTA 6 feels like the kind of Grand Theft Auto they wanted. Some want a fast power fantasy; others welcome a character-driven story and slower exploration. These preferences are legitimate, and disagreement about what makes GTA fun does not automatically make either side wrong. If you are weighing it against the previous game, read our GTA 5 vs GTA 6 comparison.

5. A wave of zero-score ratings (review bombing)

Push Square reported that Metacritic was receiving a large number of zero-score ratings and described the activity as review bombing. Its report noted repeated complaints about 30fps, the story and the game’s direction. The report suggests an unusual pattern, but it does not prove every negative rating is coordinated or fake. Genuine criticism also exists.

6. User scores are moving, unverified snapshots

Metacritic user ratings do not require a verified purchase, so the score may include people who have not demonstrated that they own or completed the game. The numbers are moving snapshots, not a stable verdict, so always attach a date and, ideally, a time when quoting a live user score. Social media comments and upvotes are not a representative survey either.

What launch-day playtime says about player interest

GTA 6 launch-day average playtime: 513 minutes on PS5 in the US and 494 minutes on Xbox globally, per Circana
Average GTA 6 playtime on November 19, 2026 among players who launched it. Source: Circana via GamingBolt.

Circana’s Player Engagement Tracker, as shared by Circana analyst Mat Piscatella on November 20 and reported by GamingBolt and VGChartz, showed that 61% of active US PS5 players and 56% of active Xbox players worldwide played GTA 6 on November 19. The players who launched it averaged 513 minutes on PS5, or about 8 hours and 33 minutes, and 494 minutes on Xbox, or about 8 hours and 14 minutes.

These percentages cover people active on their consoles that day, not every PS5 or Xbox owner. The PS5 figure is US-only, while the Xbox figure is global, so the groups are not directly comparable.

Long sessions do not prove universal satisfaction, just as a low user score does not prove widespread dislike. They do show substantial launch-day engagement while the rating debate was unfolding.

GTA 6 critic score vs user score: how they differ

Category Critics Users What it means
Score snapshot 99/100 on Metacritic PS5, reported Nov 21 About 5.4 to 5.6 out of 10 in Nov 21 reports; earlier 4.9 was reported Live figures change over time.
Who reviews? Professional gaming publications and reviewers Individual Metacritic users Different experience and review standards.
When? Reviews published before or around launch User reviews opened Nov 20 The two scores did not arrive at the same time.
Main focus Story, world design, performance, presentation and overall craft Personal enjoyment, expectations, performance and preferences Both can reveal useful but different things.

Which GTA 6 score should gamers trust?

Use critic reviews to understand the game’s design, storytelling and technical achievements. Then read detailed player reviews to learn how performance, pacing and specific mechanics feel outside a review environment. Give more weight to explanations than to a score with no reasoning. A thoughtful 6/10 that identifies a problem is more useful than an unexplained zero, just as a 10/10 is more convincing when the reviewer explains what earned it.

The 99 critic score reflects unusually strong professional praise. The much lower early user score reflects a mix of genuine disagreement, differing expectations and reported review-bombing activity. The fairest takeaway is simple: do not let either number make the decision for you. Read the reasons behind the ratings, then decide whether GTA 6’s style of open-world adventure is what you want to play. Still deciding whether it is worth the money? See our look at what GTA 6 could cost you, or browse more game reviews on E2A Games.

What do you think: are players judging GTA 6 too harshly, or are the critics overlooking issues that matter to everyday gamers?

Frequently asked questions

What is GTA 6’s Metacritic score?

Metacritic’s PS5 critic score for GTA 6 was reported at 99/100 from 152 reviews on November 21, 2026. The user score was reported at about 5.4 to 5.6 out of 10 on the same day.

Why is GTA 6’s critic score much higher than its user score?

Critics praised the world design, storytelling and presentation, while some players objected to performance, pacing and design choices. Reported review-bombing activity may also be affecting the early user average.

Did GTA 6 really have a 4.9 user score?

A report said the score briefly reached about 4.9 after user reviews opened. Later November 21 reports recorded different figures, including 5.4, 5.5 and 5.6, so 4.9 should be described as an earlier snapshot.

Is GTA 6 being review-bombed?

Push Square reported a wave of zero-score ratings and described it as review bombing. That does not establish that every negative review is fake or coordinated.

Which outlets gave GTA 6 a perfect score?

IGN, GameSpot and Game Informer each awarded GTA 6 10/10, and TechRadar gave it 5/5.

How long did players spend with GTA 6 on launch day?

Circana data reported averages of 513 minutes on PS5 and 494 minutes on Xbox among players who played GTA 6 on November 19, 2026.

Related reading on E2A Games

Sources:

Scores on Metacritic and OpenCritic are live and change over time. Figures in this article are quoted with the date they were reported.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top